'Portia's popularity will not help Rowe'

Published: Sunday | March 22, 2009



Ricardo Makyn/Staff Photographer
Portia Simpson Miller (right) leads People's National Party candidate Kenneth Rowe through the streets of the West Portland constituency on nomination day, March 6. In the background is Abe Dabdoub who contested and lost the seat against the Jamaica Labour Party's Daryl Vaz in the September 2007 general election.

Daraine Luton and Gareth Davis Sr, Gleaner Reporters

POPULAR People's National Party (PNP) President Portia Simpson Miller has walked almost every inch of West Portland in a bid to help Kenneth Rowe win tomorrow's by-election against the Jamaica Labour Party's (JLP) Daryl Vaz.

But Vaz is not scared of the 'Portia factor'. He says he is prepared to take bets that he will be beating Rowe, Simpson Miller and the entire PNP with an increased majority.

"I am not running against Kenneth Rowe. I am running against Portia Simpson Miller. Kenneth Rowe is her campaign manager because Portia Simpson has been here every single day from nomination day, knocking on every door that she can find to accept her, along with the complete top echelon of the People's National Party," Vaz says.

He also warns that "because Portia Simpson Miller has put her seal, in terms of her activities, she has a lot at stake and the fact is that I am 100 per cent confident that I will beat Portia Simpson Miller and her campaign manager".

Not daunted by comments

But Rowe is not daunted by the comments of his opponent.

"Daryl Vaz must be talking about his own situation because he constantly has to be carrying Bruce Golding into the constituency to boost his position because, on the ground, it is Kenneth Rowe that the people are talking about," Rowe declares.

"My leader is the most popular politician in this country and her presence cannot hurt my campaign; it can only help it. The one-two combination of Portia and Rowe is causing them sleepless nights and the one-two combination from the JLP (of Golding and Vaz) does not have that magnetic factor," says Rowe.

Disqualified by courts

Vaz won the seat for the JLP by 944 votes in the September 2007 general election but was disqualified by the courts as he had pledged allegiance to a foreign power, which is prohibited by the Constitution.

Vaz has said that he would be disappointed if he did not increase his majority to at least 2,000 votes.

However, Luther Buchanan, Rowe's campaign manager, says Vaz will have to find a superlative to define his disappointment.

"Anybody claiming to win this election by a majority of over 2,000 is a political neophyte," Buchanan says, while claiming that the election would be close.

"The PNP ballots will flow out of the mountains like the Swift River, into the counting centre," Buchanan says as he predicts a PNP victory.

Supporters upbeat

Buoyed by the presence of Simpson Miller, PNP supporters are upbeat about Rowe's chances of beating Vaz.

"If anybody can do it, it will be Sister P," commented Tyrone Mier, a carpenter from Hope Bay.

Sheila Adams, a hairdresser from Buff Bay, agrees.

"All the noise and excitement you are hearing about Daryl Vaz, the Labourites are truly afraid of Sister P and her ability to pull off the impossible," Adams says.

"She has quietly been going house to house and doing her thing and will, in my view, take Rowe to victory next week," Adams adds.

Simpson Miller has virtually made West Portland her home since Golding announced the by-election two weeks ago.

Julian Robinson, the PNP's deputy general secretary, tells The Sunday Gleaner that Simpson Miller has hardly been absent from the campaign field since the election was announced.

"For the last two weeks, she has been there almost every day. The fact is that we are campaigning hard and the JLP is also campaigning hard," Robinson says.

Robinson adds: "If they were not campaigning hard, then there would be no need for so many ministers of government and JLP officials to be in the constituency every day."

The prime minister and members of his Cabinet have made frequent trips to West Portland since the by-election was announced.

"Elections are based on campaigning and the Government (ministers) would be irresponsible if they did not split their time and make sure, because they know that at the end of the day, this is what keeps you in power," Vaz says.

Two election losses

Simpson Miller, despite her huge popularity, has so far lost two national elections - the 2007 general election and the local-government election that year.

Robert Montague, campaign manager for Vaz, has warned that the popularity of Simpson Miller will not save Rowe.

"This is one time when the opposition leader's reputation as a solid campaigner will not work," Montague said of Simpson Miller.

Says Montague: "She has what her own campaign adviser, Basil Waite, described several weeks ago as a 'Herculean' task, so let's see her pull this off."

The JLP currently has 31 seats in the 60-seat House of Representatives to the PNP's 28 and defeat in West Portland could make governing more difficult for Golding.

  • Rowe vs Vaz (Pt 2) - The making of the present face-off

    January 28, 2001

    JLP leader Edward Seaga unveils Rowe as West Portland caretaker/candidate.

    December 16, 2002

    The PNP's Errol Ennis polled 5,814 votes to beat Rowe, 5,523, winning by 281 votes in the 2002 general election.

    March 5, 2006

    Vaz skips from East Portland where he is constituency chairman, goes over to West Portland and defeats Rowe for the job of constituency caretaker/candidate. Vaz receives 175 votes to Rowe's 66. "I believe that poor representation has cost us this West Portland seat for the last two elections," Vaz says.

    July 29, 2006

    Vaz is officially unveiled by the JLP as its candidate for the 2007 general election.

    February 6, 2007

    Abe Dabdoub joins the PNP in Parliament.

    March 4, 2007

    Dabdoub is unveiled as the PNP candidate for West Portland in the general election.

    August 7, 2007

    Dabdoub is nominated to contest West Portland for the PNP and Vaz nominated to contest for the JLP in the September 3 general election.

    August 16, 2007

    Director of Elections Danville Walker says all 146 candidates for the general election are duly nominated. "We caution the media and the public not to fall prey to or be misled by election or political gimmickry in this sensitive period leading up to the general elections," Walker declared in the wake of claims by Dabdoub that Vaz was not eligible to sit in Parliament.

    September 3, 2007

    Vaz polls 6,977 votes to Dabdoub's 6,033 and is declared MP.

    September 27, 2007

    Vaz takes Oath of Office as member of parliament.

    December 11, 2007

    Trial begins in the Vaz vs Dabdoub election petition in the Supreme Court.

    December 14, 2007

    Chief Immigration Officer Leighton Wilson gives evidence that Vaz travelled on a United States (US) passport after he was elected MP. One immigration form produced showed that Vaz landed in Jamaica on October 7, 2007, on a US passport. It is stated in Vaz's US passport and on the landing form which he signed when he landed on October 7 that he was to leave the island by January 9, 2008, and was not permitted to work in Jamaica.

    April 11, 2008

    Chief Justice Zaila McCalla disqualifies Vaz and ruled that a by-election be held in the constituency.

    May 14, 2008

    Dabdoub appeals McCalla's ruling.

    May 15, 2008

    Vaz appeals McCalla's ruling.

    February 27, 2009

    Court of Appeal upholds the chief justice's ruling. Prime Minister Bruce Golding announces March 23 as the date for the by-election and March 6 as nomination day.

    March 1, 2009

    PNP announces Rowe as replacement to Dabdoub as PNP candidate.

    March 2, 2009

    Vaz says he wanted Dabdoub: "I wanted Dabdoub. For all the trials and tribulations that he has caused this country ... If it is a sacrificial lamb that they are sending since nomination day is Friday, then they should at least give me some good meat and not meat that I have chewed up and spat out already."

    Rowe promises battle: "We are going to pound the concrete; we are going to go to the hills and the valleys; we are going to take the fight to him and there is going to be a surprise," Rowe says.

    March 6, 2009

    Rowe is nominated to contest the by-election for the PNP and Vaz is nominated to contest for the JLP.

    March 23, 2009

    Face-off.

    West Portland election results fact file

  • 1944 (62.8 per cent turnout)

    Leopold Lynch (JLP) - 2,795

    K. Abendana (Ind) - 1,727

    Reginald Lowe (PNP) - 1,007

    Norman Thompson (Ind) - 737

    Frederick Bragg (Ind) - 295

    Walter Thompson (Ind) - 412

    C. Shirley (Ind) - 251

  • 1949 (65 per cent turnout)

    Lynch (JLP) - 5,376

    Lowe (PNP) - 4,340

  • 1955 (74.2 per cent turnout)

    Lynch (JLP) - 5,604

    E. Fagan (PNP) - 5,302

  • 1959 (76.59 per cent turnout)

    Lynch (JLP) - 5,362

    Oswald Bradshaw (PNP) - 5,293

  • 1962 (80.93 per cent turnout)

    Lynch (JLP) - 5,447

    Bradshaw (PNP) - 4,793

    Franklin Walker (PPP) - 51

  • 1967 (89.32 per cent turnout)

    Lynch (JLP) - 5,406

    William C. Smatt (PNP) - 4051

  • 1972 (81.78 per cent turnout)

    Lynch (JLP) - 4,947

    Clement Afflick (PNP) - 4,249

    Michael Dibbs (Ind) - 29

  • 1976 (87.35 per cent turnout)

    Leslie Birch (PNP) - 6,292

    Dan Green (JLP) - 5,723

  • 1980 (88.54 per cent turnout)

    St. Clair Shirley (JLP) - 6,970

    Evadney Shirley (PNP) - 5,112

  • 1989 (81.6 per cent turnout)

    Errol Ennis (PNP) - 6,848

    St. Clair Shirley (JLP) - 5,977

  • 1993 (69.66 per cent turnout)

    Ennis (PNP) - 5,847

    Holden Hammond (JLP) - 4,440

  • 1997 (66.9 per cent turnout)

    Ennis (PNP) - 6,282

    Holden Hammond (JLP) - 4,129

  • 2002 (67 per cent turnout)

    Ennis (PNP) - 5,804

    Kenneth Rowe (JLP) - 5,523

  • 2007 (72.8 per cent turnout)

    Daryl Vaz (JLP) - 6,977

    Abe Dabdoub (PNP) - 6,033

  •